Beyond the Fear: God Meets Us in the Darkness
Sermon for the Twenty-fifth Sunday after Pentecost
By Amy Sexauer MDiv '26
Ministry Fellow
The Memorial Church of Harvard University
(The following is a transcript of the service audio, Nov. 15, 2026)
May the words of my mouth and the meditation of my heart be acceptable to you, O Lord, my rock and my redeemer. Amen.
For God has destined us, not for wrath, but for obtaining salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ who died for us so that whether we are awake or asleep, we may live with Him." These are the words of Paul from his first letter to the Thessalonians, which you heard earlier. After telling his audience to be prepared for the second coming of Jesus, he reminds them and us that God has destined us for salvation, whether we are asleep or awake, because you do not need to be perfect for the Lord to meet you where you are at.
I find the relationship between the two readings you heard today interesting. Matthew is the first book of the New Testament, but scholars believe that Paul's letter to the Thessalonians was composed first, that it may be the earliest writing of all the books of the New Testament. Of course, all of these dates are a rough estimate, but chronologically we have the death of Jesus in 33 CE. This letter of Paul's is dated between 40 and 50 CE. The fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the temple happened in 70 CE. And then the Gospel according to Matthew is composed sometime around 80 CE. If we accept these dates, then Paul's letter was written before the fall of Jerusalem and the Gospel of Matthew was written after, which may explain why the tone of each is a little different.
Paul's letter is filled with hope and encouragement. The Gospel according to Matthew has hope in it too; of course, it contains the teachings of Jesus, but it also has quite a bit of anger. Maybe it's easier to have hope when the worst possible outcome you can imagine hasn't happened yet. One of the distinctive features of Matthew's Gospel is this anger. For example, in Chapter 23, there is a section known as the 7 Woes, as in, "Woe to you scribes and Pharisees." The author of Matthew writes Jesus as raging against the Jewish leadership of his time, which after the fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the Jewish community's most sacred place makes sense. Maybe the author is angry at Jewish leaders for not listening to the teachings of Jesus. Maybe he blames them for the fall of Jerusalem or sees the destruction of the temple as God's punishment against them for what he sees as their poor leadership.
Some of you may have heard before that anger is often called a secondary emotion, not because it's not authentic, but because it is often covering up a deeper feeling. Sometimes it's covering up sadness. Sometimes it's covering up fear. But this lens of anger is important for reading today's parable, the Parable of the Talents, because it explains how the parable is often understood. In this parable, we have a man who goes on a journey and leaves a portion of his money with three different slaves. The scripture says that he chooses the amount according to each slave's ability. The first slave is given five talents, the second two talents, and the third one talent. A talent, by the way, is a large sum of money.
We are told that the first two slaves are wise with their allotment and are able to double their shares, but the third slave digs a hole and hides his talent in the ground. When the master returns, he is proud of the two slaves who invested and used their money wisely. He says to them, "You have been trustworthy in a few things. I will put you in charge of many things. Enter into the joy of your master." But the master is furious at the third slave who hid his talent and did nothing with it. He calls him, "Wicked, lazy, and worthless." He commands that this slave be thrown away into the outer darkness.
Given the author of Matthew's anger and frustration with what he sees as the hypocrisy of the Pharisees, this parable is often taken as a rebuke aimed at them. They were given stewardship of something precious, and they fumbled it, and God punished them with destruction. The master's anger in this parable is framed as God's anger at those who are not wise with their gifts and blessings, and the foolish slave is a representative of the Pharisees.
If you read or hear this parable and you walk away with the idea that your fear is holding you back and that God has given you gifts to use wisely in this life, I think that's wonderful. But I struggle with this interpretation to be frank because this master character is a real jerk and I do not like thinking that he is a representative of God. Not because God isn't allowed to be angry, but because this master's actions are so directly opposed to Jesus' teaching in this gospel. I do not see the master in this parable as carrying the moral authority present in Jesus' teachings. When the master confronts the third slave, the slave says to him, "I knew that you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow and gathering where you did not scatter, so I was afraid." That doesn't sound like someone who represents the righteous anger of a just God. That sounds like someone who is consistently a tyrant.
Remember in this gospel when Jesus said, "Blessed are the poor in spirit, blessed are the peacemakers, blessed are those who are persecuted." Remember when Jesus said, "The last will be first, and the first will be last." What if we have been taught this parable upside down? The hierarchies we find ourselves in often separate us into categories where those with a lot seem to always get more, and those with nothing are always suffering. That is the world of the cruel master and not the world I want to be a part of, not the world I believe Jesus wants for us either.
So what is this slave so guilty of? Being afraid, taking something precious and doing his best to protect it instead of treating it like a replicable commodity. And as a reward for this, the slave has his gift and his responsibility taken away, and he is cast out into the darkness. The previous reading of this parable wants us to be scared of the weeping and gnashing of teeth, scared of being cast out. But you know what happens in this outer darkness? Our fearful slave is not a slave anymore. He is out from underneath the cruel machinations of any master. Maybe on the other side of our fear, there is a new and better world waiting for us too.
I'm reminded of another story in the Gospel of Matthew, the story of a man alone in a garden, bowed under the burden of great responsibility, who is alone because his friends have fallen asleep, who is scared and asking God for any other way forward, who is also cast out into the darkness while hanging from a cross, whose fear and persecution were not the end of his story, who changed the world even though he was afraid. Unlike Jesus, who had a vision of the future kingdom to come, I don't think our slave had that much hope. I don't think he intentionally undermined the system he was stuck in. I don't think he was nobly and bravely choosing not to participate in a broken system. All we are shown in the scripture is a human being in a cruel and unfair situation, afraid and doing their best to survive. Maybe from his perspective, the worst thing that could have happened to him.
I think remembering and centering this fear is important because we need to know that there is nowhere that we are called, nowhere where we are afraid to go, that God will not be with us and that Jesus has not walked on ahead of us. You don't have to have it all figured out to change the world and you don't have to know what's coming next. Your fear is not a test. Your fear is not an indication that you are doing something wrong. When we know nothing else but that we are afraid, we are still not alone. Fear is a part of being human and we can't avoid it and maybe we shouldn't.
Pope Leo XIV in his recent encyclical on artificial intelligence wrote that, "The Living God takes upon himself our weakness and transforms it into a setting for salvation." Your fears, your insecurities, they are not inadequacies. They are places where God is doing a work in you and through you. Some of the scariest moments of our lives are thresholds we must walk through towards change. The things you are afraid of, hold them up for inspection. Ask God to face them with you. Ask God what is on the other side of your fear? In the darkness up ahead, you just might find Jesus waiting for you.